In 2013, my wife Tely and I bought The Drake Oak Brook, a deteriorating landmark hotel in Oak Brook, Illinois, for $6.5 million. The property had once carried a $20 million mortgage and had been closed for roughly four years after its owner’s Ponzi scheme collapsed, resulting in a fraud conviction. Plenty of people told us we were making a mistake.
By then, I had spent two decades developing apartments, retail centers, office buildings and industrial properties, though I had never operated a hotel. My real estate mentor taught me a simple principle: a property is worth what it earns. On paper, a shuttered hotel can look worthless, and many buyers stop their analysis there. But The Drake had not closed for lack of demand. It closed because a former owner took money out of the property rather than reinvesting in it. Poor ownership is fixable. Buyers who value a distressed hotel solely on what it earns today miss what it can earn once the doors reopen and operations are restored. That gap is where the real value lies.
That insight is no longer theoretical. Today, The Drake, now part of Marriott’s Autograph Collection, generates more in annual operating profit than the $6.5 million purchase price in 2013. That result did not come from financial engineering, but rather from reopening the hotel, reinvesting in the property and restoring the guest experience and reputation that had been allowed to deteriorate.
Demand is Already There
A new hotel must persuade a market that it exists, while a landmark reopens to people who never forgot about it. I grew up a few miles away in Elmhurst, where family celebrations often meant a trip to The Drake, from Easter Sundays with my grandfather to my cousins’ weddings. Many families in the western suburbs have their own version of that story, and those memories did not fade when the doors closed.
The name carried just as much weight. Since its 1962 debut as a suburban counterpart to The Drake in Chicago, it has hosted everyone from Frank Sinatra to King Charles III. Shortly before we bought it, I spent a week on Necker Island, where Virgin Group founder Richard Branson spoke constantly about his brand. That week reframed the deal for me: we were not simply buying 154 rooms; we were acquiring a name the Midwest already trusted.
Rome Wasn’t Built in a Day
A developer can design a stunning new hotel, but no developer can give it a past. The Drake’s character was something we had to protect and improve, not invent.
Restoring a historic hotel takes more care than building from scratch, so our team had to develop skills that most modern crews never need to learn. A master craftsman now builds our furniture on-site, and we built our restaurant, COA, in under six months. Across the property’s 20 acres, we created gardens with sculptures and waterfalls. The grounds are home to more than 50 tree species and now hold Level I accreditation from ArbNet, the arboretum accreditation program administered by The Morton Arboretum, along with three wildlife habitat certifications. Having all four designations and a landscape that mature is something no new build can replicate overnight.
People Are Part of the Asset
Hiring an outside contractor was not in the budget in 2013, which became one of our greatest advantages. During the Great Recession, when failing banks dried up construction financing, I trained members of our janitorial team to help build out my commercial properties. By the time The Drake came along, they had become a dependable crew that helped us rebuild the hotel.
That approach paid off again in early 2020, when COVID shut down the industry just after we had joined Marriott International’s Autograph Collection and taken on new debt to complete the brand’s required renovations. Rather than lay anyone off, we invited every team member to join the construction effort. Roughly 70 people did, keeping their paychecks and health insurance throughout the shutdown while helping bring the hotel up to Marriott’s standards.
When the industry reopened and hotels everywhere struggled to find staff, applicants were lining up to join our team. That loyalty, and the reputation it created, never appears on an appraisal, but guests feel it every day.
Look At the Past, Then Ahead
Investors evaluating a distressed historic property tend to focus on what is broken, from deferred maintenance to years of neglect. Those costs are real, and the numbers must work, but they are also visible and finite. Harder to see is the value already in place: a trusted name and a building with history that no one could replicate today.
In 2022, less than a decade after it sat empty, The Drake was named one of the top 50 hotels in the world in the CondĂ© Nast Traveler Readers’ Choice Awards. But the value we rebuilt extended beyond the property itself. Restoring the hotel strengthened a name, a reputation and relationships that have since opened doors far beyond Oak Brook.
Our expansion into Africa began with one of those relationships: a former Drake team member from Ethiopia who is now our partner there. Together, we have developed Drake-branded projects across the continent. In March 2027, we will open the first villas at The Drake Moucha Island, a private-island resort off the coast of Djibouti and our first international project in which we hold an ownership stake. Through our advisory firm, Drake JV, we also connect Chicago’s construction, engineering, aviation and finance expertise with projects in the region, while building relationships that bring investment and travelers back to Chicago. For an owner evaluating a distressed landmark, that is another dimension of the opportunity: restoring one property can create the foundation for a much larger business.
None of that seemed possible in 2013, when Tely and I took on The Drake with no hotel experience and very little money. What we had was a willingness to pick up the tools ourselves and a clear sense of what the property was still worth. Historic hotels like it are sitting in nearly every market, waiting for an owner willing to give them a second act.
Story contributed by Jim Nagle, owner and managing partner of The Drake Oak Brook, Autograph Collection, and principal of Drake Luxury Collection.

